December 04, 2004

feelin' thinky

I grew up believing in the absolute right. Cleanliness was next to godliness. Moderation in all things. Do unto others -- that sort of thing. As a kid, the absolute right wasn’t all that difficult. The notion of being 'good' ranked somewhere on the cool scale with Kmart jeans, but the idea that you had God on your side, well…who needs to be cool when you can be pious?

As an adult (or an aspiring one, at least), the gray area is much broader, the idea of what is “wrong” much foggier and the absolute right, absolutely more questionable. Cleanliness may very well be next to godliness, but if God had to walk two avenues, he’d let the laundry pile up, too. We’ll not touch on moderation -- I’ve got a spoon resting in a pint of Godiva ice cream at present. And as for ‘do unto others,’ well that one spans an area that’s arguably the grayest among them. (And potentially, the most hazardous to put stock in.)

See, the thing with believing in an absolute right, is that in kind, you have to believe in an absolute wrong. That’s the part that I never was very good at. I’m all about making concessions. Backing down, re-drawing the line when the situation calls for it. It’s relative morality and Young Me would probably be very disappointed with my acceptance of it.

I’m awfully thinky for a Saturday night. And why? Because I just found myself at home, watching some chick flick wherein the main character was trying to do the “right” thing (as in, right by three orphaned children), and I’m screaming, “But what about YOU? You had this great job!” I’m fairly certain than on the morality scale, selfish doesn’t fall into any gray area. It’s pretty much wrong.

Right, wrong… who’s got time to figure it all out when we spend so much time just maintaining? Answer me that!

Life, if you think too much about it, can become one looming existential crisis after another. But if you don’t put enough thought into it, life can be nothing more than a road trip, with you dozing in the passenger seat. And I so don’t want to wake up in the middle of South Dakota wondering where the fuck I am.

So I’ll take my Saturday night mini-crisis for what it is, learn a little something about myself, and hope I get it together... and soon. I mean, better now than when I’m stuck with three orphans and John Corbett’s on his way over with champagne.

Posted by This Fish at December 4, 2004 11:58 PM
Comments

I'm with you.

Posted by: SR at December 5, 2004 02:49 AM

i missed you at my birthday party :(

Posted by: patches at December 5, 2004 03:44 AM

Oh Lord... whatever you do, do NOT read Nick Hornby's book How to Be Good. That sent me into a philosophical crisis that kept me up until 4am thinking about it for at least three nights in a row.

Posted by: Keith at December 5, 2004 04:51 AM

On the other hand, Po Bronson's "What should I do with my life" set me on the road to happiness and inner fulfillment, as much as a self-help book actually can.

I don't have orphans to deal with, though. Or a great job. Yet.

Some day.....

Posted by: Coomy at December 5, 2004 05:55 AM

Find a book called "The Four agreements", It is an afternoon read and a lifetime of practice. There is a chapter about doing the best you can at any given moment. absolute right is an unrealistic expectation most of the time. We have a legal system the counts on the fact that there is a gray area. Contentement with myself and confedence in my decision making ablities, made me and everyone around me much happier.

you are discovering the process of maturity dispite yourself:)

Rock on fish, your just fine.

Posted by: b at December 5, 2004 07:14 AM

Yes, I agree, don't read How To Be Good! (I just finished that last month).

Posted by: Tammi at December 5, 2004 09:39 AM

I say, if you're going to be stuck at home with three orphans, John Corbett coming over with some champagne is definitely a plus!

The movie Raising Helen (I assume that's what you're watching) got me thinking about how I would react if I were in the same position as the main character. I don't think I fared all that much better than you.

I'm new to posting 'round here - great site!

Posted by: erin at December 5, 2004 11:34 AM

As geek as this sounds I based my ideas of right and wrong on comic books when I was a kid. It replaced religion since my parents didn't really have any. I'm the guy who goes into existential crisis mode at least once a week. I am learing to moderate. I do that by attempting to set aside some time each day to meditate, to clear the mind of all thought. I discover that works best for me, not thinking. In that time I've come to realize that my life will never be as morally complex as a really good "thinking" movie or as simple as some earth shattering superhero crisis. Instead I have some basic personal principles as a bed rock and move forward with the faith that my instinct will lead me in the right direction. And if I go astray? Well there is always the ability to sincerely apologize, amend, and change. Today I really can't do that much damage to the structure of the universe.

Posted by: joe at December 5, 2004 11:44 AM

I'm not sure there's an "absolute anything" other than in a mathematical proof. I'd bet that when it comes to life in general, there are NOTHING but grey areas.

Posted by: Robotnik at December 5, 2004 12:47 PM

I had a crisis as well last night, Fish. What a coincidence. However, my crisis was more along the lines of, "Why am I here and not at home with my mommy RIGHT NOW?"

College is still rough. Everytime I think I'm over the homesickness for good, it strikes again.

Posted by: lauren at December 5, 2004 02:40 PM

I saw that movie with a career-minded all-work mom and she was absolutely cringing with guilt during the entire film. Wonder what that super-dad movie Spanglish is going to do to her?

Posted by: Mimi at December 5, 2004 03:53 PM

I've read all of your blog... mostly at my silly monkey job.... and I've come to think perhaps you and I are living in parallel worlds... as quite often a lot of the things that happen to you it appeared I was going through at the exact same time.... This seals it..... I finnished watching Raising Helen last night at 11.

:-) I totally understand your crisis.....

J.

Posted by: Jen at December 5, 2004 06:12 PM

I sometimes wonder about the right and wrong as concepts too. It seems clear to me though that almost nothing in the real world is black and white. In fact absolutist positions are a danger sign for me, which made watching the recent elections very upsetting.

Most of us never have to face a profound moral test. Films like Schindler's List leave me with a sense of admiration but also a nagging doubt. Would I have had the courage? I tell myself I do and would, but until I get to that bridge I'll never know if I can cross it...

To me, the everyday test is this: If I do this thing, am I taking advantage of someone else? If I am then I shouldn't do it.

Having said all this I have to issue this disclaimer: last night I got all teary-eyed watching Resse Witherspoon stand up for herself in Legally Blonde. So you have to discard pretty much everything that comes out of my mouth.

Posted by: Ben at December 5, 2004 06:43 PM

I don't know if I'd be strong enough to handle the three orphans of a lost sibling, but I would DEFINITELY be strong enough to handle John Corbett on his way over with the champagne. Hope your transition to adulthood makes you happy. You're still so young, enjoy it while you can!

Posted by: Steph at December 5, 2004 07:05 PM

I had that same reaction to Raising Helen! You know, I don't think it's so selfish. What kind of mother will you be if you don't have a sense of your self and goals and accomplishments that you take pride in? One with pretty dull, and potentially subconsciously sexist children! The balance is possible. Or at least, I have to believe that. So believe it with me, and that makes two of us.

Posted by: Judy at December 5, 2004 10:00 PM

OMG, you are too funny, I can sooo relate. What's right and wrong these days? It's so hard. I was feeling kinda "thinky" last night too. Because, they just hiked up the rent on my apartment (in L.A., which I know isn't as expensive as NYC but still ain't cheap), and it's like, is it WRONG to kind of mention that in passing to my mom on the phone? Just because I'm aware that the result might be her offering to increase her contribution to the V Fund? It's all so complicated, I think your pint of Godiva just might be the solution. :)

Posted by: V. at December 6, 2004 01:10 AM

Perhaps the best moral questio is this:
You have a girlfriend and some other girl (who is really hot) wants to sleep with you.
Regretfully, it isn't a dilemna I have had to worry about in my life.

Oh and did you know ice-cream is 50% air!? So at least its only really half-a-pint of fat you will be adding by eating it! And judging by your half-face photo on the homepage, eating it won't be the worst crime in the world!

Posted by: Monjo at December 6, 2004 09:35 AM

Yeah I saw that movie too. I've found Lost in the Cosmos: The Last Self-Help Book by Walker Percy helpful when I'm waxing philosophic.

Posted by: N. at December 6, 2004 10:51 AM

I can't tell you how many times I've felt "thinky" on a Saturday night - in fact, I felt thinky this past Saturday night as well while home alone watching her other hit involving sabotoging the gorgeous Matthew Mconahay. :)

Posted by: marissa at December 6, 2004 11:17 AM